One Last Time

     We've made it!!.....well...almost. It feels like just yesterday we were attempting to simply give the American Dream a definition. Now, here we are, ready to wrap up our final project and move onto our second semester of college. So far, I have found this project to be very interesting, as I have gained more insight on my chosen focus and have a solid understanding of what the dream is and how it is interpreted differently by every individual.
     My focus for this topic is the way that gender disparity in the United States hinders one's pursuit of the American Dream. Within this focus, I selected three sub-topics: politics, wages, and opportunities. My primary research began by selecting a chapter from White and Hanson's anthology, The American Dream in the 21st Century. I chose Sandra Hanson's chapter titled "Whose Dream? Gender and the American Dream". Hanson highlights numerous issues resulting for the widespread presence of gender disparity in America. Hanson first emphasizes the issues in the workforce, exclaiming that "occupations typically held by women provide lower wages" and adding that "men are paid more for what they do largely because they are men…woman needs an extra degree to receive the same earnings as a man” (80). Hanson's statements encouraged me to dig deeper into the ways that wage gaps and unjust tendencies in the workforce affect women's pursuit of the American Dream. Hanson also describes gender inequality in education, which limits females of their opportunities and freedom to become what they desire. Hanson notes the "“gendered education systems, gender tracking, & hidden curriculum...” (78), which prohibit women from their pursuit of a major that isn't seen as "feminine" by society. Finally, Hanson highlights gender differences in politics, presenting that "[a] large percent of women (relative to men) feel that the Democratic Party is more helpful" in assisting Americans' pursuit of the Dream (89). 
     I continued my research by examining multiple academic journals and discovered various ideals pertaining to the American Dream itself and more specifically to the my three sub-topics. First, in their article titled “Do Candidates Run as Women and Men or Democrats and Republicans? The Impact of Party and Sex on Issue Campaigns.”, professors of political science Kathleen Dolan and Timothy Lynch address the motives behind the seemingly purposeful influences
of politicians by examining the ways that political candidates shape their campaigns, and argue that politicians do not intentionally use their campaigns to appeal to a specific gender. 

Through “analyzing the impact of candidate sex and party on issue presentation in [their] ads” (528), Dolan and Lynch discovered that “women and men do not appear to campaign on issues where gender stereotypes might give them an advantage” (539). Next, p
olitical science professor Benjamin J. Newton discusses the vivid inequality seen in the differing wages of men and women in his article for the American Journal of Political Science titled “Breaking the Glass Ceiling: Local Gender‐Based Earnings Inequality and Women's Belief in the American Dream.” Newton argues that a correlation should exist between a woman’s salary and her attitude toward the American Dream. Newton discovered that women’s belief in meritocracy was indeed affected by their experienced wage inequality, as a larger wage gap correlated with a diminished belief that economic success was attainable (217). Newton’s findings confirm Hanson’s claim that men behold more optimism than women by revealing men’s unchanged beliefs in meritocracy despite the size of their local wage gap. Lastly, in her article titled “Programs for Undergraduate Women in Science and Engineering: Issues, Problems, and Solutions”, ADVANCE professor Mary Fox describes the gender disparity specifically seen in the academic fields of engineering and science and argues that such segregation prohibits women from acquiring opportunities and achieving independence. Fox analyzes science and engineering programs’ factors, issues, and attempted resolutions to uncover the reasoning behind the unnecessary gender discrimination present in these fields. As a result of obtaining the detailed program goals and the programs’ operational definitions of the problem, Fox found that gender issues primarily stem from "the ineffective structural orientation of the science and engineering programs" (76). Her journal article confirms Hanson’s claim that limitations of the American Dream are widespread throughout multiple fields of everyday life by illustrating the gendered education systems that divide males and females in areas of science and engineering.
     Ultimately, all of my research directed me to conclude that the presence of gender inequality throughout the nation defeats the purpose of the American Dream and limits the opportunities for women's success. Although Dolan and Lynch reveal that the division resulting from politics is not intentional and is simply manifested by society and its stereotypes, political candidates still acknowledge that such gender disparity exists, thus confirming Americans' beliefs. Although such politicians do not create the inequality, Americans sometimes feel that they allow it to continue, thus diminishing their optimism when a certain party or individual is in office. Likewise, Hanson's chapter and the articles of Newton and Fox all point in the direction that gender inequality has provided harm not only for individuals, but for the country as a whole. 

Comments

  1. I find your focus really interesting. I debated on choosing this particular chapter from The American Dream in the 21st Century but I was too indecisive to choose what direction I wanted to go with it. As a woman and a business major, I think the inequality in pay is one of the most frustrating things today. I know I will need to work much harder, get that extra degree as you pointed out, and work for longer hours over a longer period to be able to achieve the same results any man would. Another thing, something I had not thought of, that woman may feel the American Dream is overall less achievable due to the gender gap... I had never thought of this but it makes perfect sense. This is frustrating me even more, haha.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like the conclusion you came to. It makes perfect sense to me. I think you used your sources very well to come to the conclusion you did, taking in many opinions before generating your voice. Inequality today is rampant, among both race and gender, and although we've made great strides we have many more to go. I definitely feel like my dream, and many other women's dreams, are impeded by inequality and the gender gap, especially due to the fact that at a young age we're taught that we are only worth the pretty face we offer up to the world. Hopefully, one day, young girls will be taught to value themselves instead of what they see in the mirror.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You definitely chose a topic very genuine and consistent throughout history. Many people mistakenly believe that gender equality doesn’t exist today considering the fact that we have women in government and high places in business. However there have been so many cases of women reporting receiving lower pay than men. That there is not equality in any way. I believe it is even more difficult for women of color trying to avoid gender equality in the workplace because of set stereotypes. As a woman, an African American woman, I consider gender equality to be a huge obstacle for me in today’s society. Based on the sources you provided as well as the analysis and reasoning behind them, I believe you are going to do well in representing the #struggle in your essay.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Everytime I said "gender equality" I meant "inequality"!

      Delete
  4. It's crazy to think we started out trying to wrap our head around such a large topic, that being the American Dream. Yet here we are diving in head first into such important focus points. I too am analyzing gender in the American Dream. I like your angle of wages, opportunity, and politics. During my research, I found that not only do women chose female-dominant occupations, they also must earn additional degrees to even begin to equate with men. Even then, women still do not have equal wages. This topic is so interesting to me personally because we will have to withstand this discrimination as I hope to obtain a powerful position that men are able to do as well. This ongoing stigma that women are not capable of doing the same occupations as men is not only frustrating, but hurtful. I like your approach to your essay and hope these essays will give both of us more insight into the injustices that women experience in their American Dreams.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The conclusion you reached was really insightful and definitely true! It fits in very well with the sources that you explained and it flows well with the claims and analysis from them. As a woman, especially one working alongside men in college, I definitely see where the inequalities are and how discouraging they can be. It's an important point that inequalities are everywhere, even present in little things that many people would think are insignificant, but that contribute to the bigger picture of gender inequality. I hadn't thought of the inequality as relative to the American Dream before and I like the angles that all of your sources take, it's eye-opening to see how many people realize and have been analyzing this issue. I hope that someday women form anywhere feel as though the Dream is accessible again, maybe that's our job!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I do not think the reason for the gender disparity in the science and engineering fields is due to straight up systematic discrimination of women. If a girl really wanted to pursue engineering they could do it no doubt as shown by the women who are currently engineers today. I just think that women are not that interested in engineering and science fields. I feel that during childhood, boys and girls are geared towards different fields. For example, I think that parents naturally encourage the boys to do typical boy things like playing video games or play with Lego building blocks while girls will be encouraged to play with dolls or watch princess movies. I believe that these tendencies during childhood lead boys and girls to develop widely different interests and selection of major by the time they hit college leading to the wide gender disparity in the science and engineering field.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I really like the focus of your essay and your analysis that led you to your conclusion. However, I disagree with a couple points in the paper. One statement in particular mentions segregation prevents women from achieving independence. Independence from what? I think women are as free as men, and the opposing argument is a construct to help justify some unclear issues. I also disagree that women are being prevented from becoming engineers and scientists by this enigma. I think I know more women in STEM majors from my graduating high school class than men.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts